Fair odds. Sharp insights.
Roulette
The Fair Stake
Free roulette: 3 spins a day
MARKETS
BTC$56,195−8.88%ETH$1,571−9.24%BNB$516.56−9.05%XRP$0.8799−8.88%SOL$66.06−8.55%TRX$0.2992−3.43%HYPE$57.12−12.10%ZEC$705.02−16.87%LEO$9.12−1.45%Will there be no change in Fed interest…Yes 8.4¢PolymarketWill the Fed increase interest rates by 25…Yes 88.5¢PolymarketIsrael x Iran ceasefire continues through…Yes 94.5¢PolymarketFear & Greed12Extreme Fear
Bab el-Mandeb odds: is closure by December 31 at 16.5¢ value?
Deep Dives

Bab el-Mandeb odds: is closure by December 31 at 16.5¢ value?

Polymarket prices “Bab el-Mandeb Strait effectively closed by December 31?” at 16.5¢ — a 16.5% market-implied probability — but the market’s own resolution source, IMF PortWatch, has never once printed the number the contract needs in 2,792 days of data, and an independent estimate built from that record puts the true probability nearer 6%. That is a 10.5-percentage-point (pp) overpricing of the YES, and the value sits on the NO at 83.5¢.

The contract does not resolve on headlines. It resolves on a single figure: a seven-day moving average of ship arrivals at the strait of 10 or fewer. Since January 1, 2019, that seven-day average has never gone below 23.86 — and the all-time low was set this month, on August 6, 2026, before traffic recovered (IMF PortWatch, data to August 23, 2026). This Deep Dive walks the arithmetic, the case the market is making, and the three signals that would flip the read.

Methodology: how we built the 6% estimate

Every number below comes from the market’s own resolution source. We pulled the complete IMF PortWatch daily chokepoint series for the Bab el-Mandeb Strait — 2,792 daily observations from January 1, 2019 to August 23, 2026 — via the IMF’s public feature service, and reconstructed the seven-day moving average of total ship arrivals exactly as the contract specifies. That gives us the full distribution of the resolution variable, not a narrative about it.

The probability estimate is a two-stage hazard model. Stage one asks how likely a genuine escalation to physical closure is over the 125 days remaining — mining, a blockship, or an indiscriminate anti-ship campaign that ignores flag and ownership. Stage two asks, conditional on that, how likely PortWatch actually prints a seven-day average of 10 or fewer, given that ports inside the Red Sea keep receiving vessels regardless. Both stages are cross-checked against the composition of the traffic that remains.

The caveats are real. The sample contains exactly zero instances of the target event, so the estimate is an extrapolation, not a frequency. The July 13, 2026 truce collapse is a genuine regime change that makes pre-2026 data less informative. And PortWatch is derived from vessel-tracking data, which introduces a measurement channel we treat explicitly in the case against.

The market, the price, and what “effectively closed” actually means

This is a date ladder: one event, several contracts, each asking whether the threshold is breached by a listed date. The whole read starts with the resolution language, because “effectively closed” is a definitional question, not a journalistic one. Polymarket’s rule is quantitative and unusually clean:

“This market will resolve to ‘Yes’ if IMF PortWatch publishes a 7-day moving average of transit calls (‘Arrivals of Ships’) for the Bab el-Mandeb Strait less than or equal to 10 for any date between market creation and the listed date. Otherwise, this market will resolve to ‘No’.”

— Polymarket resolution criteria, “Bab el-Mandeb Strait effectively closed by December 31?” (Polymarket)

Three things follow. First, no human judgement is involved — a single published statistic settles it. Second, the condition is cumulative: any qualifying print between market creation and December 31, 2026 resolves YES, so the December contract is a strict superset of every earlier leg. Third, and most importantly, “closed” is defined at a level far below what the phrase implies in ordinary use. A 90% collapse in traffic would not resolve this market YES.

The ladder as of August 28, 2026 reads: August 31 at 0.05¢, September 30 at 5.5¢, October 31 at 10¢, December 31 at 16.5¢. Backing out a constant monthly hazard from the December price gives roughly 4.4% per month; the October leg implies about 5.1%. That is a coherent, mildly declining curve. Liquidity is respectable: $459,952 of resting liquidity, $1,172,058 of open interest and $11,443,144 of lifetime volume across the event, with $164,520 traded in the last 24 hours. The December leg itself has traded $440,506.

Is the NO at 83.5¢ value? On the evidence, yes — with a caveat about payoff shape. The contract needs the seven-day average of arrivals to fall to 10 or below. The latest published reading is 29.43 (August 23, 2026). That requires a further 66% collapse in roughly four months, to a level never observed in the seven and a half years IMF PortWatch has published. The most violent shipping shock in the entire record — the onset of the Houthi campaign in late 2023 — cut the seven-day average by 60% over 120 days, from 82.4 on October 17, 2023 to 32.9 on February 14, 2024. The market is asking for a steeper percentage collapse than that, over a shorter window, from a base already 58% below its pre-crisis level, among a fleet that has already self-selected for willingness to transit. At 83.5¢ the NO offers 19.8% gross on capital held for 125 days, against a modelled 6% loss probability.

The case for the NO: the number the strait has never printed

The strongest argument is the plainest. In 2,792 days of PortWatch data covering the full Red Sea crisis, two rounds of Western strikes on Yemen and a declared Houthi blockade, the number of days on which the strait recorded 10 or fewer arrivals is zero. Not a single day. The lowest single-day count on record is 13, on December 9, 2025. The seven-day moving average has never been below 20, and has spent exactly four days below 25 — all four of them in August 2026.

Ladder leg Price Implied prob Our estimate Edge (pp)
YES — Dec 31 16.5¢ 16.5% 6.0% −10.5
NO — Dec 31 83.5¢ 83.5% 94.0% +10.5
YES — Oct 31 10.0¢ 10.0% 3.5% −6.5
YES — Sep 30 5.5¢ 5.5% 1.8% −3.7
YES — Aug 31 0.05¢ 0.05% 0.05% 0.0

Sources: Polymarket order book, August 28, 2026, 10:23 UTC; our hazard model built on IMF PortWatch daily arrivals, January 1, 2019 – August 23, 2026. Prices are mid-market. No de-vig is applied: prediction-market cents are already probabilities.

The second argument is compositional, and it is the one the market appears to be underweighting. Over the 30 days to August 23, 2026 the strait averaged 28.2 arrivals a day, split as 9.3 dry bulk, 8.8 tankers, 4.8 container ships, 4.0 general cargo and 1.3 roll-on/roll-off vessels. Container lines — the operators that publicly announce pauses, and the ones whose withdrawal generates headlines — are already down to 16.9% of the flow. If every container ship in the world stopped transiting tomorrow, the seven-day average would fall from 29.43 to roughly 23.4, still more than twice the threshold.

To reach 10, you must remove 65% of everything. Zero out all container traffic and you still need to remove 57% of the tankers, bulkers and general cargo that remain. That residual is structurally hard to shift. A large share of it is not through-traffic at all but vessels bound for ports inside the Red Sea — Jeddah, Yanbu, Port Sudan, Djibouti, Aqaba, Massawa, Hodeidah, Aden. Routing round the Cape of Good Hope does not get you to Djibouti. The rest is regional and Houthi-exempt tonnage that has kept moving through 33 months of an active anti-shipping campaign.

“the blockade will be targeted at vessels linked to Saudi and Western interests, as was the case during the 2023-25 Houthi Red Sea anti-shipping campaign”

— Hamish Kinnear, Principal Middle East and North Africa Analyst, Verisk Maplecroft (Insurance Journal)

A targeted blockade, by construction, leaves an exempt fleet. That is the mechanical reason the floor has held at roughly 25 to 30 arrivals a day through every escalation so far, and why the August 2026 shock — the deadliest single attack of the campaign — bottomed at 23.86 rather than collapsing through it.

The case against: why 16.5¢ might be right

The market is not pricing nonsense, and three arguments deserve a fair hearing.

First, the regime has genuinely changed. The Yemen truce collapsed after a Saudi air strike on Sanaa airport on July 13, 2026. Yemen’s government reported the Houthis firing 10 missiles and four drones at west-coast targets. On August 11 the Egyptian-owned, Tanzania-flagged Tihamah was hit by three ballistic missiles; six people were killed, including three Pakistani and one Indonesian crew, plus two Yemeni troops during the rescue. This is a different conflict from the 2023–25 campaign, and Maersk instructed vessels planning to transit the strait to pause until further notice. Pre-2026 base rates understate a hot war.

Second, the price response was real and fast. Southern Red Sea war-risk premiums went from about 0.3% of hull value in mid-July to 0.75% on July 21 and above 1% by July 23, with Saudi-linked voyages from Jizan and Al Shuqaiq quoted as high as 3%. The Joint War Committee extended the listed area roughly 800 km north, pulling Jeddah and Yanbu into premium territory. Insurance is the transmission mechanism by which risk becomes an absence of ships.

“The shipping lines’ willingness to transit depends on their risk appetite in terms of risking the vessel to get shot at and their tolerance for risk regarding the seafarers’ safety”

— Lars Jensen, Chief Executive, Vespucci Maritime (Al Jazeera)

Third — and this is the argument that most worries the NO side — PortWatch is derived from vessel-tracking signals. Lloyd’s List Intelligence reports tankers continuing to call Saudi ports “often with tracking systems disabled”. If a meaningful share of the residual fleet goes dark to avoid targeting, the measured arrival count can fall much faster than actual traffic. The contract resolves on the published statistic, not on reality. A measurement collapse pays out identically to a physical one, and that is a path to YES that requires no mines and no blockship.

So is the YES at 16.5¢ a trap? Not a trap — an overpay. The dark-fleet channel is real but bounded: it would have to remove roughly two-thirds of all measured arrivals, and vessels bound for Red Sea ports have far weaker incentives to go dark than sanctioned crude carriers do. The escalation channel is likewise constrained by the Houthis’ own stated targeting policy, which has held for 33 months. Against that, the honest concession is that 16.5¢ on a tail contract is not the same claim as a 16.5% forecast. Sellers of low-probability contracts are short a violently skewed payoff — a 19.8% gross return against a total loss if the strait shuts — and a persistent few points of risk premium above the true probability is what compensates them for carrying it. Some of the 10.5pp gap is that premium rather than a mispricing. Our read is that most of it is not, but the confidence interval on a zero-event sample is wide.

Where this bet breaks

The lean on the NO at 83.5¢ rests on assumptions that could fail. It breaks if any of these fire:

  • A mining event or a scuttled blockship in the channel. Every argument above depends on the strait remaining physically navigable for exempt tonnage. Sea mines or a deliberately sunk vessel in the traffic separation scheme remove flag discrimination entirely and would stop Red Sea-bound traffic as surely as through-traffic. This is the single trigger that takes the estimate from 6% to well above the market price.
  • The seven-day average breaking 18. The record low is 23.86. A print at 18 would be an unprecedented 25% below anything ever observed and would mean the structural floor we have identified does not exist. At that point the compositional argument is void and the position should be re-underwritten, not held.
  • The Houthis dropping flag-based targeting. Kinnear’s read — and the observed behaviour of the last 33 months — is that the campaign discriminates by ownership and flag. A declared policy of striking any vessel regardless of affiliation would change the exempt-fleet arithmetic that holds the floor at 25 to 30 a day.
  • A step-change in dark activity. If Lloyd’s List or a tracking provider reports that a large share of remaining transits has switched off AIS, the measured series can decouple from reality and drift toward the threshold without any further escalation.

What to watch

The single most useful habit here is checking the resolution source directly rather than reading the news. IMF PortWatch publishes the Bab el-Mandeb series with a lag of a few days; the seven-day average is the only number that settles this contract, and it is public. As of August 23, 2026 it stood at 29.43, up from the record 23.86 on August 6 — the August shock has already partly unwound.

The August 31 leg settles within days and will make eight consecutive NO resolutions across roughly $6.3m of combined volume since March. Watch whether the December leg drifts lower on that settlement or holds, which will tell you how much of the 16.5¢ is escalation risk and how much is structural risk premium. On the ground, the markers are war-risk quotes for southern Red Sea voyages — a move above 3% for non-Saudi tonnage would be a genuine escalation signal — any expansion of the EU’s Operation Aspides mandate, and whether Maersk and the other container lines lift or extend their pause. For contrast, our read on the Strait of Hormuz normal-traffic market at 12.5¢ covers a different chokepoint under a very different resolution rule; the two are not one theme. Related tail-risk contracts include the Taiwan invasion market at 3.85¢, the US-Iran nuclear deal market at 11.5¢ and the US invasion of Iran market at 25¢.

FAQ

What are the odds Bab el-Mandeb closes by December 31, 2026?

Polymarket priced the December 31 contract at 16.5¢ on August 28, 2026 (16¢ bid, 17¢ ask), a 16.5% market-implied probability, with the NO side at 83.5¢. The shorter legs on the same ladder were quoted at 0.05¢ for August 31, 5.5¢ for September 30 and 10¢ for October 31. Our independent estimate for the December leg is 6%.

How does the market define “effectively closed”?

It resolves YES only if IMF PortWatch publishes a seven-day moving average of transit calls — “Arrivals of Ships” — for the Bab el-Mandeb Strait of 10 or fewer, for any date between market creation and December 31, 2026. Otherwise it resolves NO. There is no judgement call and no news component; a single published IMF statistic settles it, which is why the definitional question matters more here than the geopolitics.

Is the YES at 16.5¢ value?

Our analysis says no. The threshold has never been reached in 2,792 days of published data spanning the entire Red Sea crisis. Hitting it needs a 66% fall from the current 29.43 reading in about four months — a steeper percentage collapse than the original Houthi campaign produced over a comparable window, from a base already 58% below pre-crisis levels. The value sits on the other side.

What could make the closure market resolve YES?

Realistically, one of two things. A physical closure — mines, a blockship, or an anti-ship campaign that stops discriminating by flag — would halt even the exempt and Red Sea-bound traffic that currently holds the floor near 29 arrivals a day. Alternatively, a large enough share of the remaining fleet switching off vessel tracking could drag the measured statistic below 10 without traffic actually stopping.

How much traffic still goes through the strait?

An average of 28.2 arrivals a day over the 30 days to August 23, 2026: 9.3 dry bulk, 8.8 tankers, 4.8 container ships, 4.0 general cargo and 1.3 roll-on/roll-off. That is roughly 58% below the 74.6 daily average of the January-to-October 2023 baseline, but it has been broadly stable at 25 to 30 a day for more than two years.

What would change this analysis?

A seven-day moving average printing below 18 would invalidate the structural-floor argument entirely and require the estimate to be rebuilt. So would credible reporting of mining in the channel, a Houthi statement abandoning flag-based targeting, or evidence that a large share of remaining transits has gone dark on AIS.

This article is informational analysis only and is not betting or financial advice. Odds and prediction-market prices move constantly; every price quoted is a timestamped snapshot, not a live line. There is no such thing as a guaranteed bet — past results and model estimates do not guarantee outcomes. Do your own research.

18+Gambling carries financial risk and can be addictive. 18+ / 21+ depending on jurisdiction. Never bet more than you can afford to lose. If you or someone you know needs help, visit GamCare (UK), call 1-800-GAMBLER (US), or see our Responsible Gambling page.

Tobi Opeyemi Amure

Written by

Tobi Opeyemi Amure

Editor and content strategist for crypto and iGaming news. Former contributor at Watcher Guru, Investing.com, and Traders Union. Named among LinkedIn's top 333 Web3 creators. Covers esports betting, sports wagering, and gambling regulation.

Get the latest crypto, gambling and betting insights. No spam, just alpha.

By subscribing you agree to our Privacy Policy. Unsubscribe anytime.