Fair odds. Sharp insights.
Roulette
The Fair Stake
Free roulette: 3 spins a day
MARKETS
BTC$62,697−2.63%ETH$1,775−1.70%BNB$580.91−1.94%XRP$0.9615−1.35%SOL$73.34−1.28%TRX$0.3105+0.84%HYPE$66.77−2.93%ZEC$904.62−4.87%XMR$501.39−0.93%Will Anthropic's market cap be less than…Yes 38.9¢PolymarketWill the Fed increase interest rates by 25…Yes 91.5¢PolymarketWill the Fed increase interest rates by…Yes 6.3¢PolymarketFear & Greed10Extreme Fear
Polymarket NYC mayor odds: is Mamdani exit at 4.5¢ value?
Deep Dives

Polymarket NYC mayor odds: is Mamdani exit at 4.5¢ value?

Polymarket’s “Zohran Mamdani out as mayor of NYC before 2027?” contract trades at 4.5¢, a 4.5% market-implied probability that New York’s mayor ceases to hold the office before December 31, 2026. Our base-rate estimate puts the true number near 2%, a 2.5-percentage-point (pp) edge on the NO side — and the order book says that entire edge is worth about $45.

That last number is the story. The probability read is defensible: no mayor of New York City has left office mid-term since William O’Dwyer resigned in August 1950, and none has ever gone in a first year. But an edge you cannot size is an academic exercise. This Deep Dive walks the base rate, the removal statutes that make the YES side non-zero, and the liquidity arithmetic that settles the question.

Methodology: how we built the 2% estimate

The estimate is a base-rate model, not a forecast of any particular scandal. We took every mayor of New York City since the 1898 consolidation — 21 of them, Robert Van Wyck through the incumbent — and counted substantive mid-term departures by death, resignation or removal. Three qualify; John Hylan’s resignation one day early in 1925, for pension purposes, is excluded as a technicality. We divided those three by the 128.6 years of continuous mayoral service between January 1, 1898 and this snapshot, giving an annualised hazard of 2.33%. Scaled to the 135 days remaining on the contract, that is 0.86%.

We then adjusted upward, not downward, to roughly 2%, for factors the series does not capture: a more adversarial relationship between City Hall and Washington, and the fact that the contract resolves YES on an announcement of resignation or removal, not its effective date — a looser trigger than the historical cases. Actuarial mortality for a man of the mayor’s age contributes under 0.1% across the window and is immaterial. The obvious caveats: three events is a very small sample, the modern mayoralty is institutionally more insulated than the 1930s version, and “adjusted upward for the political environment” is a judgement, not a measurement.

The market, the price, and the very small book

The contract resolves YES if Mamdani ceases to be mayor for any period between taking office and 11:59pm ET on December 31, 2026. Polymarket’s own resolution text also specifies that an announcement of resignation or removal resolves the market immediately, regardless of when it takes effect. He was sworn in on January 1, 2026 — the Office of the Mayor lists him as the 112th mayor of New York City, and was still issuing routine policy announcements on August 17, 2026, the day before this snapshot.

The price has decayed almost monotonically. YES opened at 14.5¢ on November 6, 2025, two days after the general election and before the transition; it fell to 5¢ in the first week of January as the inauguration passed without incident, oscillated between 6.5¢ and 8.5¢ through the spring, and printed 4.5¢ today — its all-time low. The 1¢ bid-ask spread is genuinely tight for a market this small, which is the one thing arguing that the quote is informative.

Everything else argues that it is not. Lifetime volume is $70,053 and displayed liquidity is $15,588. For scale, Polymarket’s live Los Angeles mayoral election market has done $13.4m in volume with $258,028 of liquidity. The NYC ouster contract is not a thin corner of a deep market; it is a thin market.

Is the NO side at 96¢ value? On the probability alone, yes — but marginally, and only in small size. If the true probability of a mid-term exit is 2%, fair value for NO is 98¢, so the 96¢ best offer is two cents cheap. That is a real 2pp edge. The problem is what the book will actually absorb. There are 895.5 shares offered at 96¢ — $860 of capital. Take that and the next level costs 97¢, worth one cent of edge. The level after that is 98¢ — fair value, zero edge. In total, roughly $4,814 of capital captures about $45 of expected value before the price reaches the point where the trade stops being profitable. The edge is real, correctly signed, and economically trivial.

Side / level Price Implied prob Our estimate Edge (pp)
YES (exit before 2027) 4.5¢ mid 4.5% 2.0% −2.5
NO — best offer 96¢ (895.5 shares, $860) 96.0% 98.0% +2.0
NO — second level 97¢ (2,725.2 shares, $2,643) 97.0% 98.0% +1.0
NO — third level 98¢ (1,337.8 shares, $1,311) 98.0% 98.0% 0.0

Sources: Polymarket CLOB order book and gamma API snapshot, August 18, 2026; our base-rate model. Prediction-market prices in cents read directly as probabilities, so no de-vig is required; the 1¢ quoted spread is the only friction adjustment.

“Thin markets are not automatically inaccurate, but they are less reliable. The key question is whether skilled traders still have enough incentive and ability to trade.”

— Theis Ingerslev Jensen, Professor of Finance, Yale University
(CNBC, July 2, 2026)

That framing is the right one here. The incentive to trade this contract is a few cents of edge; the ability is capped at $860. The same CNBC analysis found roughly 70% of closed Polymarket markets between 2021 and May 2026 saw under $10,000 in volume, so this contract is not an outlier — it is the norm.

The case for the NO side: an extraordinarily stable office

New York City’s mayoralty has been remarkably durable. Since consolidation in 1898, exactly three of 21 mayors have failed to finish a term. William Jay Gaynor died in September 1913, in his fourth year. Jimmy Walker resigned in September 1932, in his seventh, under the pressure of the Seabury investigation. William O’Dwyer resigned in August 1950, in his fifth, to become ambassador to Mexico. That is the complete list.

Two features of that list matter more than the headline rate. First, all three departures cluster in a 37-year window that ended 76 years ago. Not one mayor has left office mid-term since O’Dwyer — through fiscal collapse in the 1970s, through the Koch-era corruption scandals, through Giuliani, through the pandemic. Second, and more directly relevant, no New York mayor has ever left office in a first year. Gaynor, Walker and O’Dwyer were all well into established administrations when they went. The contract is asking about a first-year mayor at month eight.

Mayor Departed Year of term Mechanism Years since
William Jay Gaynor September 1913 4th Died in office 113
Jimmy Walker September 1932 7th Resigned 94
William O’Dwyer August 1950 5th Resigned 76
All others (18 of 21) — — Completed term —

Sources: historical record of New York City mayors since the 1898 consolidation; 3 departures across 128.6 years of service = 2.33% annualised, or 0.86% across the 135-day contract window.

What would it actually take for this contract to resolve YES? Four mechanisms exist and each has a high bar. Resignation is voluntary, and there is no public indication of it. Removal by the Governor under New York Public Officers Law § 33 requires the Governor to serve written charges on the mayor and grant an opportunity to be heard in his defence — a formal, slow, highly visible process that has never once been carried through against a New York City mayor. Criminal process is slower than it looks: under New York Public Officers Law § 30 an office is vacated only on conviction of a felony or a guilty plea, not on indictment. Eric Adams is the proof — indicted in September 2024, he served every remaining day of his term. The Charter’s inability provisions require a formal finding by a committee of city officials. Death is the residual, and for a man in his thirties the actuarial contribution across 135 days is under 0.1%.

One structural fact closes much of the window. New York’s gubernatorial election falls on November 3, 2026, but the winner’s term does not begin until January 2027. Any removal inside this contract’s life must therefore come from the sitting governor — who weighed that power against Adams in February 2025 and declined to use it.

The case against: why the market may be right and we may be wrong

The steelman for 4.5¢ is straightforward, and it starts with the resolution language. This contract does not require a completed removal. An announcement of resignation or removal resolves it YES immediately, and it resolves YES if the mayor ceases to hold office “for any period of time” — including a temporary suspension that is later reversed. Our base-rate series counts only permanent, completed departures. On a like-for-like basis the historical rate is therefore an understatement of what this specific contract is measuring, and a genuinely careful modeller would push the estimate up rather than down.

The second problem is that a 128-year base rate is the wrong reference class if the present is genuinely unusual. Base rates work when the future resembles the sample. If City Hall’s relationship with Washington is meaningfully more hostile than anything in the post-1950 series, the market — pricing today’s information rather than a century of averages — has the better claim. Three events is also a desperately small sample; the confidence interval around 2.33% per year is wide enough to contain the market’s number comfortably.

Third, and most practically: our edge is 2pp on a contract trading at 4.5¢. That is well inside the error bars of any model built on three observations. On a market with a 1¢ spread, a 2pp “edge” is two spreads wide. If the true number is 3% rather than 2% — an adjustment far smaller than the uncertainty in the estimate — the edge at the 96¢ offer halves to one cent and vanishes at the second level. This is less a disagreement with the market than a rounding difference dressed up as a view.

“Ask yourself who would buy Mamdani at 95% to make 5% with the potential for a total loss. It seems like a stupid trade even if you think Mamdani will win.”

— Bill Ackman, founder and chief executive, Pershing Square Capital Management, writing on X during the 2025 mayoral race, as reproduced by Rajiv Sethi, Professor of Economics, Barnard College, Columbia University
(Imperfect Information, November 1, 2025)

Ackman was talking about the election contract, not this one, but the objection transfers exactly. Buying at 96¢ to earn four cents, with the whole stake at risk if a single headline lands, is a payoff most people decline on sight — which is why the YES side keeps a floor under it. Sethi noted that a five percent return in under a week “is hardly negligible”; over 135 days rather than a week, 4.2% is a considerably duller proposition.

Where this bet breaks

The lean toward the NO side at 96¢ rests on assumptions that could fail. It breaks if any of these fire:

  • A felony indictment of the sitting mayor. Not because an indictment removes anyone — it does not, as Adams demonstrated — but because it would move this contract violently regardless. The market would reprice the perceived odds of a resignation under pressure, and the 96¢ NO side would be marked down long before any legal process concluded.
  • The Governor serves formal charges under Public Officers Law § 33. Not speculation about removal, not a press conference — the actual service of written charges and the scheduling of a hearing. That is the observable, documented step that converts a theoretical statutory power into a live process, and it has never been completed against a New York City mayor.
  • The price moves back above 8¢. The contract has traded between 4.5¢ and 8.5¢ all year. A sustained break above 8¢ on volume materially above the $70,053 lifetime figure would mean informed money is arriving, and on a book this thin the reasonable inference is that the newcomers know something the base rate does not.
  • The mayor becomes a candidate for another office. The O’Dwyer precedent is the one mid-term departure that had nothing to do with scandal — he left for an ambassadorship. A credible move toward a statewide or federal role is the underrated path to YES, and would not look like a crisis.

What to watch

The contract expires on December 31, 2026, giving it 135 days from this snapshot. There is no scheduled catalyst in that window — no election, no confirmation vote, no statutory deadline — which is itself the point: this is a market on the unscheduled, and the absence of a catalyst is why the price decays.

The levels worth tracking are narrow. YES printed an all-time low today at 4.5¢ having opened at 14.5¢ in November 2025; the year’s range is 4.5¢ to 8.5¢. Movement inside that band is noise on a book where $860 sits at the best offer. Movement outside it is information. Watch too whether the $15,588 of displayed depth grows — if this market stays this thin into December, the conclusion here does not change whatever the model says.

FAQ

What are the odds on the Polymarket NYC mayor market right now?

The “Zohran Mamdani out as mayor of NYC before 2027?” contract trades at 4.5¢ mid — 4¢ bid, 5¢ ask — with a last trade at 4¢, as of August 18, 2026. In prediction markets the cents read directly as a probability, so 4.5¢ is a 4.5% market-implied chance that the mayor ceases to hold the office before the contract expires on December 31, 2026. That is the market’s all-time low; it opened at 14.5¢ on November 6, 2025.

Is the NO side at 96¢ value?

On probability alone it is cheap by about two cents, since a 2% true probability implies 98¢ fair value. In practice the edge is negligible. Only 895.5 shares are offered at 96¢ — $860 of capital — and the book reaches fair value at the third level. Deploying roughly $4,814 captures about $45 of expected value in total, before accounting for the opportunity cost of locking that capital up for 135 days.

How could a New York City mayor actually be removed from office?

Four routes. Voluntary resignation. Removal by the Governor of New York under Public Officers Law § 33, which requires written charges and an opportunity for the mayor to be heard in his defence. Conviction of a felony or a guilty plea, which vacates the office automatically under Public Officers Law § 30 — an indictment alone does not. And the Charter’s inability provisions, which require a formal finding by a committee of city officials. None has ever removed a sitting New York City mayor; the three historical mid-term departures were two resignations and one death in office.

Why is this market so thin?

Lifetime volume is $70,053 and displayed liquidity is $15,588. Contracts on unscheduled events with no catalyst attract little two-way interest: there is nothing to trade around and the NO side ties up capital for months to earn a few cents. Polymarket’s live Los Angeles mayoral market, by comparison, has turned over $13.4m — roughly 191 times the volume of this one.

Does the prediction market’s 2025 result mean it is reliable here?

Not necessarily. The 2025 New York City mayoral election market handled $429m in volume and settled correctly, but that was a heavily-traded contract on a scheduled event with abundant polling. This one is a low-probability, low-volume market on an unscheduled event with no polling and no catalyst. Accuracy on the first says little about price quality on the second.

What would change this analysis?

A felony indictment of the sitting mayor, the service of formal removal charges by the Governor, a sustained move above 8¢ on volume well above the market’s lifetime total, or credible movement toward another office. The last is the underrated one — the only non-scandal mid-term departure in New York history was William O’Dwyer leaving for an ambassadorship in 1950.

For related work on low-probability contracts, see our analysis of the Congress stock trading ban market at 11¢ and the Greenland contract at 8¢. For the heavy-favourite side of the same problem, see the 2026 midterms market at 84¢, the Israel next prime minister market and the 2028 Democratic nomination market.

This article is informational analysis only and is not betting or financial advice. Odds and prediction-market prices move constantly; every price quoted is a timestamped snapshot, not a live line. There is no such thing as a guaranteed bet — past results and model estimates do not guarantee outcomes. Do your own research.

18+Gambling carries financial risk and can be addictive. 18+ / 21+ depending on jurisdiction. Never bet more than you can afford to lose. If you or someone you know needs help, visit GamCare (UK), call 1-800-GAMBLER (US), or see our Responsible Gambling page.

Tobi Opeyemi Amure

Written by

Tobi Opeyemi Amure

Editor and content strategist for crypto and iGaming news. Former contributor at Watcher Guru, Investing.com, and Traders Union. Named among LinkedIn's top 333 Web3 creators. Covers esports betting, sports wagering, and gambling regulation.

Get the latest crypto, gambling and betting insights. No spam, just alpha.

By subscribing you agree to our Privacy Policy. Unsubscribe anytime.